What is it we want to go back to?

Farmed and Dangerous.

Huh? Since when is raising food on farms dangerous? Apparently Chipotle restaurants think it is. This February, Chipotle is releasing an online comedy show on Hulu called just that, “Farmed and Dangerous.”

As a farmer myself, certainly my radar went up when I heard about this campaign.

Part of me feels defensive, but I also try not to take things too seriously. I’m sure some of you may eventually see this show, enjoy it, and laugh. It’s comedy after all. If you do, I hope you’ll read my post too. I’m not thrilled that a food company, while trying to seem ethically minded and concerned about farming practices, is actually making fun of farmers as they pass judgement on modern agriculture.

But it got me thinking. I thought about our food system of today, the outcry against it, and began to wonder…

What is it we want to go back to?

Here is my perspective.

20130920-204537.jpg

I asked myself this question again, “What is it we want to go back to?” as pondered the increasingly conflicted food chain I am part of.

I live in middle-of-nowhere Minnesota, with the nearest town having a population of about 100 people. It’s too small for its own post office or zip code.

We are farmers. We care for and milk cows. We grow feed for these cows and their offspring. We sell the milk our cows produce to a nearby cooperative, which processes the milk into butter, cheese, and dairy ingredients. It’s something this family farm has done for over 100 years.

Simple, right?

But even in middle-of-nowhere Minnesota, I hear growing clamor about the evils of large farms and corporate agriculture. I hear people casually mention how they only want to buy ethically-raised food, and I see the selection of things like almond milk, soy milk, and hemp milk growing in our local grocery stores.

Somehow, the day to day activities of a farm like ours have become alien to a whole generation-plus. When people visit our farm they love seeing the cows and milking equipment, but so many people don’t have the chance to visit a farm.

20140210-224335.jpg

They just hear about farms with “hundreds of cows” and assume they are industrial and uncaring. That couldn’t be farther from the truth on our dairy.

I also often hear people remark they want to get back to natural foods — like things used to be. In the good old days, food was nutritious, wholesome, local, less processed, and better. Right?

It’s convenient to ignore the fact that food was produced with back-breaking labor, many farmers were subsistence farmers, and food borne illness was much more common because of contamination, lack of refrigeration, or poor preserving methods.

I try to take the whole food debate in stride because I know most people are well meaning and just want to do what’s right for the world. They want to eat healthy and support responsible agricultural practices.

And so do I. I believe in ethically raised food to my very core.

I want to see agriculture be a sustainable system that produces good food people can afford and that they feel good about eating.

So, let’s switch gears for a minute.

Meat Processing

I’ve had the opportunity to visit large, modern meat and poultry processing plants. They process a large quantity of meat that comes from a large number of animals. They’re efficient, clean, and regulated.

On the flip side, we raised a few chickens and turkeys in our backyard this summer.

20140207-114457.jpg
(You maybe followed along with my poultry project saga from the day our chicks arrived at the post office.) My husband and I butchered about 10 of these birds ourselves.

It was a lot of work.

We found a processor for the remaining turkeys and chickens because I didn’t want to spend any more Saturdays in autumn freezing my fingers trying to pluck chickens.

Which is better?

For my part, I say neither. I think both produce good, nutritious food. Raising chickens in my backyard may be less sustainable economically because it was quite costly. After buying feed, equipment, and paying processing fees, we ended up with some expensive birds.

It was a fun project for us and we sold some eggs and meat, but on this scale there is exactly 0% chance we’ll break even on the endeavor.

Larger farms aren’t perfect either. Because they have lots of animals in one place they need to be extra careful with monitoring animal health and how they handle waste like manure. When farms are larger though, the government requires an environmental plan to make sure the manure is applied to land responsibly for fertilizer. Larger farms = larger regulations, which means the consumer can be assured there’s much more oversight.

I’m also grateful things aren’t the way they used to be where everyone had to butcher all their own meat!

Growing Vegetables

I know not everyone even eats meat. So what about vegetables?

Well, they are a lot of work too. We garden as a hobby, and we spent many hours to grow and freeze enough tomatoes and peppers for our own use, plus make sauerkraut. We had various fresh veggies for eating, and we canned about 10 jars of salsa. Beyond that? Well, we’d have a serious lack of food for the winter if we had to raise everything ourselves.

20140207-132528.jpg
It’s intensive to plant, weed, and tend row after row of vegetables.

In today’s world, most people simply don’t have the time or land resources to raise their own food. This they understand with certainty. All while demand grows for food that is speciality, organic, local, small-scale, pastured, natural, or some combination there of — that is still as affordable, safe, and abundant as its more conventionally produced counterparts.

As far as natural goes, ALL food is full of chemicals. It always has been. At its most basic level, food and everything else is made up of elements from the periodic table. (Remember high school Chemistry?)

Conventionally grown foods may use approved pesticides to control bugs and weeds. Organic foods may use organic-approved pesticides for the same reason. I don’t know which is better, but I do know no farmer wants weeds taking over their fields or bugs in their apples or lettuce.

And I think you know how I feel about antibiotics. On our farm, if I have a baby calf sick with pneumonia I will not hesitate to give her the antibiotic she needs. I believe in the benefits of modern medicine, much like I’m sure you do for yourself or your own children. I don’t want to see antibiotics used recklessly or without proper prescriptions and veterinary oversight.

If a food animal is treated with antibiotics, a specified withdrawal time must be past before that animal is slaughtered. It ensures that all antibiotics are out of the animal’s body. This isn’t only good practice, it’s law.

Even though I have my own beliefs, I still recognize that every farm is different. Farms need to find a niche and system that works for their geography, interests, and goals. There are small conventional farms, large organic farms, vice versa, and everything in between.

This post is not a referendum on farm type.

This post is about the right to access and choice in food.

Good conditions for animals, workers, and food safety all contribute to ethical food. I happen to think using modern knowledge and practices is a critical part of attaining that.

It doesn’t mean you can’t butcher your own chickens in the backyard if you want to. It does mean we need a diverse food system that provides food options at reasonable prices for every budget.

Your food choices do not have to be your neighbors choices. And that’s okay. We are fortunate to have a food system that is so much safer than that of one-hundred years ago that you can feel good about a broad range of choices.

It’s really more of a complex web — this thing called the food chain. The one thing I do know is we continue to need farms of all kinds. You and I both need to eat, and I’m thankful for the abundance that we can chose from each day. I will also continue steadfast in my belief that farmed does not equal dangerous.

20140207-132144.jpg

About Lisa

Hi, I'm Lisa. Dairy farmer's wife and Minnesotan to the core, I write about rural farm life, running down country roads, and the food, faith, and family that bind everything together. Follow along on my journey.
This entry was posted in Agriculture ( in general), Cooking and Foods and tagged , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

36 Responses to What is it we want to go back to?

  1. tjscholten says:

    Amen. Thank you for thinking and writing.

  2. I agree! We are lucky to live in a country where we have food choices; organic, natural, conventional. I recently wrote about this topic as well (http://moderndayfarmchick.com/2014/01/28/lets-take-the-fear-out-of-food/) I hate that the media puts such a stigma on large agriculture and modern-day farm practices. No matter what consumers choose in the food isle, they can know it is safe!

  3. Katie says:

    This is a great post! My husband and I talk about this all the time, but I don’t think we ever say it so well.

  4. Helen says:

    I am relatively new to reading. Your blog, and I have you’re enjoyed your posts. We farm too, beef cows and in Virginia, so we don’t have nearly the struggles of weather you all do. Anyway, I just wanted to say that your post was very well put. I think it is easy to lose sight of the choices we have in this country with regards to food, and assume that big is bad when it comes to farming. The little guy can do just as much wrong.

    • Lisa says:

      Hi Helen; thanks for taking the time to read & comment. It seems like winter all over the country has been challenging this year, so hope yours hasn’t been too bad!

  5. Great post! I can relate very much in that I love to have a garden and love to pick some of my neighbor’s eggs every now and then, but really, it’s just a hobby. I am so thankful for modern agriculture and so proud to be a part of it!

    • Lisa says:

      Thanks for sharing, Rita. I do think it’s great when people can raise their own food, and I’m also proud to help produce food for those who don’t. πŸ™‚

  6. As my 92-year-old dad says, “I lived through the old days once. We did what we had to do. It wasn’t fun the first time, so why would I want to do it again?”

  7. Great post with plenty of thought and insight! I think there is plenty of room for all types of operations.

  8. Leah James says:

    Love the post! Well said!

  9. I agree! We need a variety of options for different budgets. I think it’s somewhat ironic that as the demand grows for local and organic food, it becomes increasingly hard for those farms to produce enough while maintaining those practices.

  10. Thank you! I agree 100%. We also have a dairy farm (SW MN) and raise a handful of chickens and garden. There are pros and cons to all types of farms. We do what we believe is the most efficient and healthiest for our animals. I get very irritated with those who have no idea what it takes to raise their food, but are very opinionated on how it should be raised.

  11. “Farmed and Dangerous” better describes me behind a tiller than it does than any of the farms I’ve visited. Dairy farmer’s go the extra mile (even in sub-zero weather mind you) to produce safe, delicious and nutritious dairy foods. While dairy farming doesn’t look like it did in the past, cow comfort remains a top priority. If the cows aren’t “happy, happy, happy” they won’t produce enough milk (any mom that’s nursed her own babies can attest to that). Lisa, thank you for your rational voice and for the hard work you do so that my family can enjoy fresh, wholesome dairy!

  12. Great post. Thanks for sticking up for the ag industries!

  13. Megan says:

    I agree with a lot of what you have said, but when you wrote, “I see the selection of things like almond milk, soy milk, and hemp milk growing in our local grocery stores.” your saying it’s a bad thing? Then, you ended with, “This post is about the right to access and choice in food.” Isn’t that contradictory?

    • Lisa says:

      Hi Megan, thanks for your feedback. You’re right that I didn’t explain myself in the best way here.

      I’m fine with people buying these alternative beverages if it’s what they prefer taste or nutrition-wise. I really do support choice. However, when I hear friends, bloggers, and others say they buy these beverages because they think dairy cows are mis-treated, then I feel badly. I know how caring most dairy farmers are, so it’s hard to know some people are avoiding dairy milk based purely on mis-information.

      Hope this provides some clarification. Let me know if you have other questions.

  14. tmgieseke says:

    Maybe this is a reflection on advertising in general…when was the last time you saw a truthful ad for anything? This may be a long ways from the true center, but it is only slightly outside the lines of normal. I think advertising just took a page out of Political Campaign 101 – and we are aghast.

    • Lisa says:

      I know ads are their own game, but that doesn’t stop my reaction to those that really miss the mark. Farming IS food, so I’ll keep strong in my position on this one. πŸ™‚

  15. Tanya says:

    excellent.
    A young lady I know who grew up on a farm pointed me here. I do not farm, but I am married to a large animal veterinarian also here in Minnesota. We often talk about this subject, and in the context of ‘be careful what you wish for’. Not every American can afford to purchase food that comes from small, organic etc farm operations. Not to put these operations down, but for those farmers to earn a living, they need to be paid more for their product because it generally cost more to produce due to a variety of factors. If our country were to loose all modern, conventional farms, there are plenty of other producers world wide who do not have the regulations in place that the US does. Food stores will still want to stock product in a variety of price points, and making a product available to lower income families may require importing more foreign raised animal products. I generally have no problem with the global market place, but personally would prefer my meats to come from the well regulated US market.

  16. Pingback: My Challenge to Chipotle on CNN Eatocracy | Agriculture Proud

  17. Pingback: Checking the Facts on Chris Leonard’s “The Meat Racket” | Agriculture Proud

  18. Thank you SO much for writing this! I was raised in Nebraska among a couple relatives who have a dairy farm and raise cattle. This debate I see in the media and hear everywhere has been so disturbing to me, because it does not line up with my experience with farmers and the way food is produced. Thanks again for taking the time to share!

    • Lisa says:

      Hi Val; thanks for your feedback. I’m glad you take the time to think about the realities you’ve seen in farming. It sounds like you grew up in a wonderful area! The overwhelming number of regular farmers quietly doing a good job don’t make headlines, but we really are the norm. πŸ™‚

  19. Nancy Schuster says:

    I agree. I shared your blog on facebook. Well done.

  20. Thanks for your writing . The thing that gets me is all the false information being put out by those who advocate organic only.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s